IMO, regardless of whether or not Nash is a risk of being a bust in New York, his upside on that team with all the talent he is surrounded by is much better than the talent surrounding Getzlaf this year. Both players of similar stats the last few years but during tournaments in which both players have been surrounded by equal talent, Nash has been placed on the top line for scoring on more occasions, has MVP history in these scenerios and has higher individual stats in those particular situation. Being that New York is a much more complete team which will allow Nash the ability to be creative offensively I expect him to fufill his potential on the Rangers. Getzlaf needs a similar change of address to a more complete team to obtain similar stats to Nash's potential in New York. Fantasy situation Getzlaf gets traded to the Oilers and rides on the top line there and maybe he has a higher offensive upside than Nash in New York.